Determinants of Ethical Actions: An Analytical Overview
Q: Explain the major determinants of ethical actions with suitable example.
In the study of Ethics and Human Interface, the morality of a human act is not determined in isolation. It is assessed based on specific factors known as Determinants. These determinants act as the criteria to judge whether a Human Action is right or wrong, virtuous or vicious.
1. Major Determinants of Ethical Actions
According to classical ethical philosophy, there are three primary components that determine the moral quality of an action:
- The Object (Nature of the Act): This refers to the intrinsic nature of the action itself—what is actually being done. Some acts are considered Intrinsically Evil (e.g., murder, perjury) regardless of the motive, while others are good or indifferent.
- The Intention (Motive/End): This is the Purpose or the "why" behind the action. A good intention cannot justify an inherently bad act (e.g., stealing to give to charity), but a bad intention can make a good act unethical.
- The Circumstances: These are the Situational Factors surrounding the act (Who, where, when, how). They can increase or decrease the degree of goodness or badness of an action but cannot change an inherently evil act into a good one.
2. Illustrative Example
Consider the action of Using Force by a police officer during a public protest:
- Object: The physical act of using a baton. In itself, it is a Neutral Act of law enforcement.
- Intention: If the motive is to Maintain Public Order and prevent a riot, the action leans toward being ethical. If the motive is Personal Vendetta, it becomes unethical.
- Circumstances: Using force against a peaceful, non-violent assembly is unethical, whereas using Proportional Force against a violent mob armed with weapons may be considered ethically justified.
Definition of Key Term
Proportionality: An ethical principle stating that the response to a situation should be commensurate with the threat or need. Example: A civil servant using minimal force to disperse a crowd rather than lethal force demonstrates the principle of proportionality.
Conclusion
In conclusion, for an action to be considered Morally Good, all three determinants—Object, Intention, and Circumstance—must be sound. As the adage goes, "Bonum ex integra causa, malum ex quocumque defectu" (Good results from a whole cause, evil from any defect).
Word Count: 248 words